- "Donny… Donny! Get down off of that exhibit, and I told you, spit out that gum!"
- ―Nina Carnegie[src]
Donny was a student in Ms. Englert's third grade class. On New Year's Eve of 1959, Nina Carnegie chaperoned his class for a sleepover at Ryan Amusements. During the night, the rioting of the Rapture Civil War began, and his class was trapped in the park. After Nina died, the class apparently begged Carlson Fiddle for supplies, which he did not give. Donny's eventual fate is unknown.